Skip to main content

On democracies and free meals

The good thing about IIT Kanpur is the active student involvement in the administrative processes (at least those related to students). This, I have never had a doubt about. I believed that the average intellectual of the IITians would rise beyond shallow greed to enable this system to be progressive. But over the last one year or so, I feel saddened to have been proved wrong.

Around a year ago, a proposal was received to hike the electricity charges to be borne by the students in lieu of increased electricity rates. A subsequent proposal was made to recover electricity charges from each hostel individually. The proposal aimed at generating greater accountability amongst the residents(students) regarding electricity usage. This system was finally implemented in the start of the present semester. Through all the back and forth discussions, the students remained silent about the new proposal, its shortcomings etc. until they received their first bill at the end of January. Then began a series of absurd discussions and arguments that have saddened me time and again.

Through these 6 months I have seen students spread misinformation first out of ignorance and then out of deliberation to serve the end they had in mind. I have seen them refuse to accept facts or update their opinions in light of new knowledge. I have seen them arm-twist statements and opinions till they toe the line. I have never seen more ignoramuses in my life.

I observed an egotistical unwillingness amongst the students to accept the flaws in their arguments/claims. This process of thought amongst young adults is frightening and terrifying. All that’s left after months of deliberation are the same claims they began with. “The institute should subsidise our lifestyle, the government should subsidise our lifestyle, we on our part shall claim no responsibility for it. “

As an office bearer, part of the hostel administration I (along with others) was expected to sign a letter addressed to the director.  I was informed to sign on the sheet only if I agreed. But would a blank against my name imply assent by silence? Did it appear as another deliberate attempt to highlight only one set of opinions? Or was it reluctance to record un-favourable opinions out of fear that they might gather more of their kind?

Any democratic setup/ process presupposes informed opinion. It presumes that every individual, that is to be a part of the setup, has access to unbiased information to form this opinion, and that the process/ setup that gather these opinions merely consolidates them and does not collude them. Hence, in presence of misinformation and biased referees this system fails.

That “we”, the “present” (future?) of the world are already corrupt enough in thought and action, that we cannot run a simulacrum democracy successfully, makes me numb. It breaks me to see that at an age when we should be broadening our vision, we choose to live in a voluntary myopia. We want low tax rates, and subsidies on everything. We want a rise in pay over time due to inflation, yet we do not want to accept inflation and increase in prices. We want free education, but want no one to be bothered about our grades. We want facilities and comforts, yet we do not want to be held responsible for them. We do not want to be responsible for the resources use, we do not want to be responsible for the waste we generate, we do not want to be responsible for the dying trees, for the thirsty animals and the homes we have destroyed. We do not want to be responsible for the miserable lives on which the "sales" thrive. Time and again, “we” fail ourselves collectively, and yet expect the society exclusive of us to somehow be different. 

It is easy to say change begins at home, or practice what you preach, yet it is difficult to resist the temptation to rush at every board that screams free meals. 

Comments

Joyee said…
Very aptly written! I am feeling something similar in an entirely different setup.
I wonder when will we understand that "with power comes a responsibility, and if we ignore the latter we are bound to face the consequences".
May 6, 2016 at 12:49 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Damsel in Distress Syndrome

Many years ago, a male friend quoted, “a girl/woman in a relationship is somehow more attractive to other guys”.  I didn’t really give a thought to it then, it could have been well merely his opinion. But what with guys liking girls who are already with someone else (and vice versa) I thought it wasn’t as simple as that. At a broader, abstract level, we as social creatures, seek conformity in our actions, a kind of acceptance. We are more willing to conform to something that has been already accepted. More than often we conform to social codes, rules, without questioning them because they already have some acceptance for them. We tend to believe that anything that has been accepted should be worth accepting. The other way of looking at it, and this one’s a personal favourite, is the Damsel-in-Distress Syndrome. Okay, there’s no such syndrome really, and I came up with the name, but it fits. So a couple of years ago, I had this friend who thought a girl was driving him nut...
1 comment
Read more

smoke off yer life

Its been some time since my last post…..but I was preoccupied with other matters… Back to ma writin What is the difference between addiction n habit…if any!! The first thing that I turned to for an answer was a dictionary! In the GREAT DICTIONARY (no adjective, the dictionary I refer is itself called the GREAT DICTIONARY…nt oxford, m a bit unorthodox) i found this: ADDICTED is defined as being physically dependant on a certain thing, or, being devoted to a particular interest or activity HABIT was defined as a settled or regular tendency or practice!! This may sound drab, n my reader may wonder what I am heading to, but I have a point to make, n I hope you bear up wid me The definitions above are not complete, what about mental dependence? I come to the crux of the matter now!! SMOKING: is it an addiction or a habit? its not supposed to make u mentally dependent...but then ppl do behave lyk they r aft some tym...lyk i need a cig to think, to relieve ma tension!!...
2 comments
Read more

a story

Once upon a time, th ere was a bird . He was adorned w it h tw o perfect wings and with glossy, colorful, marvelous feathers. In short, he was a c reature made to fly about freely in the sky, bringing joy to everyone who saw him. One day, a woman saw this bird and fell in love with him. She watched his flight, her mouth wide in amazement, her heart pounding, her eyes shining with excitement. She invited the bird to fly with her, ant the two traveled across the sky in perfect harmony. She admir ed and venerated and celebra ted that bird. But then she thought: he might want to visit far-off mountains! And she was afraid, afraid that she would never feel the same way about any other bird. And she felt envy, envy for the bird’s ability to fly. And she felt alone. And she thought: I’m going to set a trap, the next time the bird appears, he will never leave again.’ The bird, who was in love, returned the following day, fell into the trap and was put in cage. She ...
2 comments
Read more